Bill Cara

Using Fair Value to Trade the Open

June 6, 2025

Today’s Pre-Market Snapshot: DJIA

  • Yesterday’s Close: 42,379.74
  • Latest Fair Value (FV): 42,649
  • Implied Sentiment Premium:
    FV – Yesterday’s Close = 42,649 – 42,379.74 = +269.26
    Translation:
    Futures are pricing in a +270 point premium above fair value.
    This screams aggressive bullish sentiment.

What This Means for the Open

  1. Predicted Open:
    Yesterday’s Close + Premium = 42,379.74 + 270 ≈ **42,650**

  2. Why Fair Value Matters Here:
    • Fair value (42,649) already includes mechanical adjustments (overnight interest costs + dividends).
    • The extra +270 points = pure trader conviction that the Dow will gap up hard.

Tactical Insights for Traders

What the Premium Tells You:

  • Urgency: A +270 premium at 8:50 AM ET means buyers are piling in aggressively.
  • Catalyst-Driven: This isn’t “drift” — it’s reacting to news (e.g., May private non-farm payrolls at 139K vs 126K forecast).
  • Arbitrage Fuel: Arbs must buy Dow stocks at the open to lock in the futures premium → self-fulfilling rally.

Key Risks:

  • Gap Fades: If the premium is too extreme (like +270), day traders often “fade the open” (sell the pop).
  • Volume Check: Thin pre-market volume? The gap could deflate by 10 AM.
  • News Catalyst: If the rally driver (e.g., Jobs report) disappoints at 10 AM, the earlier market sentiment-driven gains will likely reverse.

How to Trade This

  1. Bullish Scenario:
    • Ride momentum if:
      • Volume confirms (NYSE TICK > +800),
      • Dow futures hold gains past 9:15 AM ET.
    • Entry: Buy open, target 42,750 (next resistance).
  2. Bearish Fade Scenario:
    • Short at open if:
      • Premium shrinks below +200 by 9:25 AM,
      • Key stocks (e.g., UNH) show weak pre-market bids.
    • Target: Gap fill toward 42,450.

This particular blog serves as a foundation for my upcoming Trade Tactics Daily morning report, designed specifically for day traders. Here, I examine key market trends, sector movements, and actionable insights, enabling traders to navigate opportunities with confidence and precision.